What a Techno-Economic Analysis Includes, and When You Need One

A techno-economic analysis (TEA) estimates how a process could perform and what it could cost at a stated scale. It connects the physical process to its economics: what goes in, what comes out, what equipment is needed and what operating it would require. Berkeley Lab’s review of TEA for biofuels and bioproducts describes that connection between process evidence and cost estimates.

I start with the decision the model needs to support. A team comparing two production routes needs a different analysis from one deciding which experiment to fund.

What inputs does a TEA need?

The first inputs are the product specification, the intended scale and the boundary of the study. Does the analysis include product recovery, waste treatment and shared utilities? Both alternatives need a comparable boundary.

The technical and economic inputs usually include:

  • Process evidence: feedstock composition, conversion or yield, operating conditions, material flows and energy requirements.
  • Production assumptions: capacity, operating hours, downtime and product recovery.
  • Cost basis: equipment and installation estimates, feedstocks, utilities, labor, maintenance and waste handling.
  • Financial assumptions: the currency and cost year, project life and any financing assumptions needed for the chosen calculation.

I keep measured values separate from estimates and development targets. A yield achieved in a laboratory experiment is evidence under those conditions. A higher yield that the team hopes to achieve belongs in a separate scenario.

NETL’s carbon-conversion TEA guide provides a useful example of documenting the design basis and assumptions. Its technology-specific defaults should not be copied into an unrelated process.

What should the analysis produce?

Depending on the question, outputs can include capital and operating costs, resource requirements, production cost per unit, or the selling price required to meet a stated financial target. A calculated selling price does not establish what customers will pay.

A PNNL study of microalgae conversion shows the connection clearly: process simulation produces material and energy balances, which feed the cost calculation. Those outputs then support sensitivity analysis.

For a decision, I also want to know which inputs could reverse the result. Sensitivity analysis varies assumptions; scenarios examine plausible combinations. A range of scenarios is not automatically a probability estimate.

The deliverable should let someone inspect the assumptions and update the model when better evidence arrives. The recommendation should identify what to measure next and explain why that measurement matters.

How long does a TEA take?

There is no single turnaround time I can promise before reviewing the process and the available data. A screening comparison using an existing model involves less work than a study that requires process definition, reconciled measurements or equipment quotations.

I scope the schedule around the model that already exists, the alternatives to compare, missing inputs and review time. If a missing measurement controls the decision, I would flag that dependency before agreeing to a completion date. A larger spreadsheet cannot replace the measurement.

When is it worth doing?

A TEA is useful when the result could change what you fund, build or test. That can be early in development: identifying a cost bottleneck may help you avoid optimizing a variable that has little effect on the overall process.

I would first ask what decision is approaching and what evidence could change it. If the answer cannot affect the next step, the analysis may be premature. If the process lacks enough definition to model, the useful first task may be an evidence review or an experiment plan.

The objective also needs to fit the setting. In the space-biomanufacturing TEA case study, the analysis considered a mission constrained by launch mass. That analysis was delivered, but the system it describes has not been built, flown or tested in microgravity. It illustrates why the system boundary and the resource being optimized deserve attention before modeling begins.

Common mistakes

Comparing unlike cases. Different cost years, product specifications or operating assumptions can make a comparison misleading.

Treating targets as demonstrated performance. Keep today’s evidence visible alongside the assumptions about a future process.

Leaving out the difficult downstream work. Product recovery, utilities and waste handling belong inside the boundary when the decision depends on them.

Reporting precision the inputs cannot support. A detailed output needs an equally clear account of its uncertainty. For environmental claims, a separate lifecycle assessment may also be needed; cost alone does not establish environmental benefit.

For a process decision, my techno-economic analysis consulting service produces an inspectable Objective-Function TEA Model, documented assumptions and a decision memo. The scope follows the evidence available and the choice you need to make.

Dr. Vernon McIntosh

Dr. Vernon McIntosh

Independent practice in biotech, data, and AI/ML

Vernon McIntosh writes about hard biology, data systems, and the practical edge of AI in scientific work. If a post raised a question you want to talk through, book a call or reply by email.

Keep in touch

New essays by email

New essays arrive as they publish. Every so often there is a shorter note when something in the work is worth passing along. If you would rather not do email, the same posts go out on the RSS feed.

Your email is used only for these essays. See the privacy notice.

Send Vernon a message

For consulting inquiries or employment opportunities. A valid return email is required. All other fields are optional.

Messages are processed by Web3Forms and emailed to Vernon. Please do not include confidential information. See the privacy notice.

Prefer email? consulting@vernonmcintosh.com